1. Is the article interesting or thought-provoking?
2. Is it novel in its methods or conclusions?
3. Does it counter current thinking?
4. Is it especially timely?
5. Does it address a longstanding question or debate in the field?
6. Would it change thinking on that topic, if it were true?
7. Is it rigorous and the argument logically sound?
沒有留言:
張貼留言